Barbacoa vs Carnitas

Barbacoa vs Carnitas. Both dishes are made from pork, but they are prepared in different ways and have distinct flavors. Carnitas has a slightly sweeter and less spicy flavor than barbacoa.

Both dishes are delicious and perfect for serving at parties, family gatherings, or any other special occasion.

However, depending on your taste preference, you may prefer one over the other. Some people may prefer the bold and spicy flavor of barbacoa, while others may prefer the sweeter and more subtle flavor of carnitas.

Barbacoa vs Carnitas

Two popular dishes are barbacoa and carnitas. While both dishes have similar elements, there are some notable differences between them.

Barbacoa is a form of Mexican barbecue that originated in the states of Hidalgo and Veracruz.

The dish usually consists of beef, lamb, goat, or pork slow-cooked in a pit with spices.

Carnitas, on the other hand, is a traditional Mexican dish made from slowly simmered pork.


Barbacoa is a Mexican dish that is slow-cooked, usually using the entire head of a cow.

The dish is often seasoned with spices like cumin and chili powder and mixed with onions, garlic, and tomato sauce. It is typically very tender and flavorful.

In contrast, carnitas are also Mexican dishes that are slow-cooked, but instead of using a whole head of the cow, only the pork shoulder is used.

Carnitas is also often seasoned with spices, but commonly uses oregano and thyme, as well as citrus juices for added flavor. Unlike barbacoa, carnitas is usually served as a main dish, not a taco or burrito filling.


Carnitas is a Mexican dish made with braised or simmered pork, usually in lard.

Unlike barbacoa, carnitas is cooked until the meat is tender and lightly browned.

The traditional preparation of carnitas includes simmering the pork in a copper pot, often with lard, orange juice, garlic, bay leaves, oregano, cumin, and salt.

The final step includes frying the meat in its own fat until it is golden brown and crispy. Carnitas can be served as tacos, enchiladas, tamales, burritos, or with other dishes.

The difference between barbacoa and carnitas

Barbacoa and carnitas are two traditional Mexican dishes that are often confused. Barbacoa is made with beef or lamb that is slow-cooked in a maguey (a type of agave) leaf. This gives the meat an intense flavor and a moist, tender texture.

In terms of flavor, barbacoa has a smoky, earthy taste that comes from the maguey leaves. The pork in carnitas has a rich, salty flavor thanks to the lard.

When it comes to preparation, barbacoa is typically cooked over an open fire while carnitas is cooked in a pot.

Which is a better option

When it comes to deciding between barbacoa and carnitas, it really depends on the occasion. Both are Mexican-style dishes made with slow-cooked meat, usually pork or beef, but they have different flavors.

Barbacoa is usually spicier and has a smokier flavor, while carnitas is more savory and has a more subtle flavor.

In terms of convenience, carnitas may be the better choice as it is typically cooked in large batches so it can be easily stored and served over several days.

It can be served as tacos or a burrito bowl and is usually cooked in smaller batches with lots of spices and herbs, making it a more complex and flavorful dish.

Overall, there is no wrong choice when deciding between barbacoa vs carnitas – it really depends on what kind of flavor profile and convenience you’re looking for.

Whether you choose barbacoa or carnitas, you’re sure to enjoy a delicious and unique Mexican-style meal.

Barbacoa vs Carnitas

The Last Word

Barbacoa vs Carnitas. Both dishes are made from slow-cooked pork, but the cooking methods and flavors are different. Barbacoa is typically made by cooking the pork in a pit or underground, while Carnitas are cooked in a pot.

Barbacoa has a smoky, earthy flavor, while Carnitas are crispy and slightly sweet. Both are delicious and perfect for a hearty meal.

Ultimately, the choice between Barbacoa and Carnitas comes down to personal preference and the specific flavor profile that one is looking for in a dish.

Related Guides